Hi Maria,
Thanks for the screencast!
Unfortunately, it looks like WP All in One Migration uses a custom compression algorithm that Local does not support at this time.
Your best bet is to use a tool like the following to manually extract the .wpress file: https://github.com/fifthsegment/Wpress-Extractor
Once you do that, you can re-compress it as a zip and import it into Local as long as it contains at least one .sql file and the wp-content folder.
If you don’t want to go that route, it looks like the other alternative is to purchase a Pro license of All in One Migrator.